Stargate: Universe = Stargate: Atlantis?

I’ve been a big fan of the original Stargate: SG-1 SciFi series that ran for 10 seasons and had two direct-to-DVD movies.  Just like with any successful TV show, producers created a spinoff series titled,  Stargate: Atlantis which I also watched on and off when I had spare time. I thought Atlantis was an ok show, but after 6 seasons it seemed to duplicate a lot of the storylines from the SG-1 series. Now, MGM has created a new series called Stargate: Universe which I watched the pilot episode last night. After watching this first episode, I really question whether this series is “new”.

Universe has a lot of similarities to the previous Atlantis series, which I’ve sumarized below:

  • Universe is set on a newly discovered Ancient spaceship — Atlantis is set on a newly discovered Ancient city (actually, a spaceship also)
  • The Universe crew sets out to explore their new surroundings — the Altantis crew sets out to explore their new surroundings
  • The Universe crew are in dire straits with a dying ship and must figure out how to fix the life support — the same for the Altantis crew
  • The Universe crew are really, really far away from Earth and can’t go back home — same for the Atlantis crew (at least for the first few seasons)
  • The Rodney McKay (brilliant scientist) character on Atlantis has been replaced by Dr. Rush and a college-aged young man who figure out an Ancient problem by playing a video game
  • Major Sheppard on Atlantis is equivalent to Lt. Scott on Universe
  • etc.

A lot of similarities… maybe too many. The filming of Universe is a direct copy of Battlestar Galactica, where they use a lot of hand-held cameras (ala, the show 24). They even showed a steamy sex scene which seemed to be another direct copy of Battlestar Galactica. It was obvious the producers were trying to piggyback off the success of BSG— maybe too obvious.

So will Universe be a hit? I really don’t think so. I think the concept of the Stargate series has suffered “franchise fatigue”, a term quoted and used for the last Star Trek series, Enterprise. I’ll predict that Universe will recycle old stories from the past Stargate series, as well as from Star Trek and BSG. Whatever the case, I’ll probably watch the next few episodes and see if the writers and producers can really come up with a fresh new show, or just show the same old stuff.


7 thoughts on “Stargate: Universe = Stargate: Atlantis?

  1. Robert Davis says:

    I watched the first 2 episodes. It better pick up here in the next 2 or I think I’ll find something else to watch on Fridays.

  2. zunetips says:

    I’ve only watched the first episode, and have the 2nd one on my Zune for watching tonight. I have a feeling it’s just going to be recycled scripts from the previous Stargate episodes. Different enemy, same danger scenario, same solution. I do hope they show some different stuff or I’ll also be watching something else.

  3. zunetips says:

    Well, I did watch the 2nd episode last night and it was really boring. A lot walking around in the sand on a planet looking for a dried lake bed, and when they finally found it they fixed the air scrubbers on the ship… not so exciting. They are obviously trying to copy Battlestar Galactica with the filming technique and “character stories” (which is boring also). I’d like to see some fresh ideas and concepts that they’ve never discussed before in the Stargate series.

  4. Dylan` says:

    I think Universe is not god as Atlantis. Because Atlantis has more action more than Universe that why i think they should bring Stargate Atlantis back.

  5. Gerardo says:

    Yeah completely agree with Dylan!

    Stargate Universe lacks of action and technology!!!

    Stargate Atlantis was much better!!

    I am watching 10th episode and don’t like it but i will continue watching it cause i don’t have anything else to watch.

  6. Jeff says:

    You’re absolutely right. I was watching with my dad and he said stories were a copy from BSG and Babylon 5 and Stark Trek. Eg. Star Trek Next Generation – The Loop when they had to go through a loop of dreams to get the right solution! Young had dreams of dying until he figured it out.

  7. zunetips says:

    I wonder if the writers of these shows know that they are copying old stories, or do they think what they came up with is original? I’m sure you can take any modern story and trace it back to some story in an old SciFi novel, etc.

Leave a Reply

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in: Logo

You are commenting using your account. Log Out / Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out / Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out / Change )

Google+ photo

You are commenting using your Google+ account. Log Out / Change )

Connecting to %s